Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 3557362" data-attributes="member: 22779">While technologically D&amp;D might be considered medieval, althought that's problematic as well, socially, it never, ever has been.Consider alignments.Do you allow your paladins to rape women?&nbsp; Medieval ones certainly could have.Do you have higher ranked people randomly demand items from the PC's without compensation?Do you allow your PC's to take whatever they want from people of lower station?Do you execute PC's for wearing the wrong color?Do you execute female PC's for wearing pants?Do you excuse PC's from laws once they gain title?Do you allow PC's to gain title?The list goes on and on.&nbsp; Morally, D&amp;D has always been modern because a Dark Ages moral system is pretty repugnant to most of us today.&nbsp; Look at the definition of Good in any edition.&nbsp; That's certainly not what would be considered Good under a Feudal system.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 3557362, member: 22779"] While technologically D&D might be considered medieval, althought that's problematic as well, socially, it never, ever has been. Consider alignments. Do you allow your paladins to rape women? Medieval ones certainly could have. Do you have higher ranked people randomly demand items from the PC's without compensation? Do you allow your PC's to take whatever they want from people of lower station? Do you execute PC's for wearing the wrong color? Do you execute female PC's for wearing pants? Do you excuse PC's from laws once they gain title? Do you allow PC's to gain title? The list goes on and on. Morally, D&D has always been modern because a Dark Ages moral system is pretty repugnant to most of us today. Look at the definition of Good in any edition. That's certainly not what would be considered Good under a Feudal system. [/QUOTE]

Verification