Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="ECMO3" data-source="post: 9778176" data-attributes="member: 7030563">The part you quoted doesn't say what is in red and it is a stretch to draw this conclusion, I would also say Truestrike is an attack roll made as part of a spell.Moreover, I will point out that Innate Sorcery feature itself does NOT say &quot;spell attack&quot; so if something &quot;needs&quot; to say to say the exact words &quot;spell attack&quot; and without those words it means another kind of attack, then the Innate Sorcery ability must be referring to a different and broader set off attacks and not just &quot;spell attacks&quot;.This is a MORE permissive interpretation.&nbsp; If I am to take this &quot;need&quot; like you say, then Innate Sorcery must refer to all attacks made as any result of a sorcerer spell since it does not specify &quot;spell attack&quot;. So the extra attack I make with Haste would get advantage or the attacks I make when polymorphed would get advantage since it does not just apply to &quot;spell attacks&quot;.For me it is pretty simple - if the spell and thereby the attack can be counterspelled then it is an &quot;attack roll of a sorcerer spell&quot; and it would have advantage.&nbsp; So Truestrike yes, Booming Blade yes, Chill Touch yes, Chromatic Orb yes, attack from Bigby's Hand no, attack by a summoned creature no, extra Haste attack no, attack with a Shadowblade or Flameblade no.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="ECMO3, post: 9778176, member: 7030563"] The part you quoted doesn't say what is in red and it is a stretch to draw this conclusion, I would also say Truestrike is an attack roll made as part of a spell. Moreover, I will point out that Innate Sorcery feature itself does NOT say "spell attack" so if something "needs" to say to say the exact words "spell attack" and without those words it means another kind of attack, then the Innate Sorcery ability must be referring to a different and broader set off attacks and not just "spell attacks". This is a MORE permissive interpretation. If I am to take this "need" like you say, then Innate Sorcery must refer to all attacks made as any result of a sorcerer spell since it does not specify "spell attack". So the extra attack I make with Haste would get advantage or the attacks I make when polymorphed would get advantage since it does not just apply to "spell attacks". For me it is pretty simple - if the spell and thereby the attack can be counterspelled then it is an "attack roll of a sorcerer spell" and it would have advantage. So Truestrike yes, Booming Blade yes, Chill Touch yes, Chromatic Orb yes, attack from Bigby's Hand no, attack by a summoned creature no, extra Haste attack no, attack with a Shadowblade or Flameblade no. [/QUOTE]

Verification