Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Wik" data-source="post: 5210498" data-attributes="member: 40177">That would be the crux of where we differ, then.&nbsp; I'm seeing it as an adaptation of a 2e setting into 4e rules, with 4eisms added on for marketing purposes.&nbsp; So, we're coming at it from different perspectives.&nbsp; Fair enough.Still, I'd like to think that if Dark Sun had never been released, and that this was the first time Athas had ever seen the light of day, I'd still look at the feywild and say &quot;why does this need to be here?&quot;&nbsp; To be honest, though, I probably wouldn't.&nbsp; So, fair enough. But I really don't see the point of a feywild on Athas.&nbsp; &quot;Desert cranked to 11&quot; implies that the Athasian deserts are NOT the worst place to be.&nbsp; &quot;Super Magical Desert&quot; implies that it is a more serene place, which also doesn't work.&nbsp; Which basically means Athasian Desert = Feywild Desert... in which case, why include the latter at all?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Wik, post: 5210498, member: 40177"] That would be the crux of where we differ, then. I'm seeing it as an adaptation of a 2e setting into 4e rules, with 4eisms added on for marketing purposes. So, we're coming at it from different perspectives. Fair enough. Still, I'd like to think that if Dark Sun had never been released, and that this was the first time Athas had ever seen the light of day, I'd still look at the feywild and say "why does this need to be here?" To be honest, though, I probably wouldn't. So, fair enough. But I really don't see the point of a feywild on Athas. "Desert cranked to 11" implies that the Athasian deserts are NOT the worst place to be. "Super Magical Desert" implies that it is a more serene place, which also doesn't work. Which basically means Athasian Desert = Feywild Desert... in which case, why include the latter at all? [/QUOTE]

Verification