Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Erik Mona" data-source="post: 1816903" data-attributes="member: 2174">&gt;&gt;&gt;Hmm, I was never very sure if things went that far...I mean, Jozan in the Iconics novels is a cleric of Pelor, but we won't be seeing New Koratia on the Greyhawk maps, right? Nor the original Adventure Path (The Sunless Citadel through Bastion of Broken Souls) despite the same thing. It's interesting to ponder if using even the &quot;basic D&amp;D&quot; pantheon makes an adventure necessarily Greyhawk by default, since there are not only no other connections, but sometimes also other things that seem to fly in the face of it being GH.&gt;&gt;&gt;A point of clarification. I should have said &quot;Any adventure with a cleric of Pelor *PUBLISHED BY ME WHILE I EDIT DUNGEON* is a Greyhawk adventure.&quot; I'm already using the pantheon, because it is part of the core rules. I can either make the brief background bits and city names and such conform to the setting as well, or I can choose to ignore the fact that I know Greyhawk like the back of my hand and can effortlessly make the material useful for a sizable portion of the readers, at no cost to the majority who will just convert it to their campaigns anyway (and God bless 'em for it).It's a clear choice for me, folks. And an easy one.--Erik MonaEditor-in-ChiefDragon &amp; Dungeon</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Erik Mona, post: 1816903, member: 2174"] >>> Hmm, I was never very sure if things went that far...I mean, Jozan in the Iconics novels is a cleric of Pelor, but we won't be seeing New Koratia on the Greyhawk maps, right? Nor the original Adventure Path (The Sunless Citadel through Bastion of Broken Souls) despite the same thing. It's interesting to ponder if using even the "basic D&D" pantheon makes an adventure necessarily Greyhawk by default, since there are not only no other connections, but sometimes also other things that seem to fly in the face of it being GH. >>> A point of clarification. I should have said "Any adventure with a cleric of Pelor *PUBLISHED BY ME WHILE I EDIT DUNGEON* is a Greyhawk adventure." I'm already using the pantheon, because it is part of the core rules. I can either make the brief background bits and city names and such conform to the setting as well, or I can choose to ignore the fact that I know Greyhawk like the back of my hand and can effortlessly make the material useful for a sizable portion of the readers, at no cost to the majority who will just convert it to their campaigns anyway (and God bless 'em for it). It's a clear choice for me, folks. And an easy one. --Erik Mona Editor-in-Chief Dragon & Dungeon [/QUOTE]

Verification