Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Caligulaa" data-source="post: 1778266" data-attributes="member: 24585">Disagree!I really don´t understand your list. It seems to be built quite heavily on nostalgia. For how can &quot;Tomb of Horrors&quot; be better than &quot;Return to the Tomb of Horrors&quot;? I mean, really!? This also goes for the other &quot;Return to...&quot; adventures. Do you really mean that the newer versions are worse than the oldies? And how can you leave out great adventures like the epic &quot;Dragonmountain&quot; that so many players loved. I also miss &quot;Axe of the Dwarvish Lords&quot; and &quot;Night Below&quot;. &quot;Rod of Seven Parts&quot; should be there as should &quot;Die Vecna Die&quot;. How can anyone list &quot;The Forge of Fury&quot; as one of the best ever? Have you really played it? It is simple, boring and has no feeling what-so-ever! In Sweden a lot of players are VERY critical to this list. Somebody started a thread on a Swedish D&amp;D forum about this list and criticism is HEAVY. You should really motivate your choices and explain the criterias for making the list. Please, leave nostalgia out of it! Fredrik Bermar, Stockholm, Sweden.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Caligulaa, post: 1778266, member: 24585"] [b]Disagree![/b] I really don´t understand your list. It seems to be built quite heavily on nostalgia. For how can "Tomb of Horrors" be better than "Return to the Tomb of Horrors"? I mean, really!? This also goes for the other "Return to..." adventures. Do you really mean that the newer versions are worse than the oldies? And how can you leave out great adventures like the epic "Dragonmountain" that so many players loved. I also miss "Axe of the Dwarvish Lords" and "Night Below". "Rod of Seven Parts" should be there as should "Die Vecna Die". How can anyone list "The Forge of Fury" as one of the best ever? Have you really played it? It is simple, boring and has no feeling what-so-ever! In Sweden a lot of players are VERY critical to this list. Somebody started a thread on a Swedish D&D forum about this list and criticism is HEAVY. You should really motivate your choices and explain the criterias for making the list. Please, leave nostalgia out of it! Fredrik Bermar, Stockholm, Sweden. [/QUOTE]

Verification