Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Manbearcat" data-source="post: 9420891" data-attributes="member: 6696971">I don't have time to post anything new on this subject and it looks like this thread has probably reached its apex of input and is winding down.&nbsp; But, since you've summoned me, I'll aggregate the things I've written about this subject recently if the lead poster is looking for any further input on the subject (if they're not, that is fine as well!).&nbsp; Lets see:&lt;A reply elsewhere to someone saying DW is clunky and burdened to with Classic D&amp;D dungeoncrawling conceits&gt;&lt;Same commenter as top replying asking about the incorporation of typical D&amp;D stats being evidence of a burden of Classic D&amp;D influence&gt;&lt;A separate commenter, a player in one of my 1-10 DW games, makes the follow-on comment:I think I disagree that DW play &quot;defies D&amp;D conventions.&quot; I've said that my experience of DW was pretty much exactly like what I think a good game of D&amp;D is, and I know &lt;name redacted&gt; didn't experience a wide variance in feel between your games and mine.&gt;Yup.&nbsp; That's it from me.&nbsp; If you get something out of that, lead-poster, great!&nbsp; If you've already got enough input from others to have made up your mind...also great.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Manbearcat, post: 9420891, member: 6696971"] I don't have time to post anything new on this subject and it looks like this thread has probably reached its apex of input and is winding down. But, since you've summoned me, I'll aggregate the things I've written about this subject recently if the lead poster is looking for any further input on the subject (if they're not, that is fine as well!). Lets see: <A reply elsewhere to someone saying DW is clunky and burdened to with Classic D&D dungeoncrawling conceits> <Same commenter as top replying asking about the incorporation of typical D&D stats being evidence of a burden of Classic D&D influence> <A separate commenter, a player in one of my 1-10 DW games, makes the follow-on comment: I think I disagree that DW play "defies D&D conventions." I've said that my experience of DW was pretty much exactly like what I think a good game of D&D is, and I know <name redacted> didn't experience a wide variance in feel between your games and mine.> Yup. That's it from me. If you get something out of that, lead-poster, great! If you've already got enough input from others to have made up your mind...also great. [/QUOTE]

Verification