Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mournblade94" data-source="post: 5049935" data-attributes="member: 74608">Are there really enough people to buy into this sort of thing?&nbsp; We have a 3rd edition professional update already (Pathfinder), and I find many other 3rd edition clones just simple rehashes.&nbsp; Its like people trying to publish by including their house rules in the system core.Pretty much all of the 3rd edition clones are not worth getting as a whole.&nbsp; There are individual areas that they might improve, but as a whole they are not better than 3rd edition.It seems like people that still want to play D&amp;D who were involved with 3rd edition will A) keep playing 3rd edition B) play Pathfinder or C) go to play 4e.These 3rd edition derivatives seem like alot of work put out for about 10 people.&nbsp; I understand wanting to do it as an intellectual exercise or for personal satisfaction, but to actually have it taken seriously as an independent game by the gamer population seems vastly unlikely.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mournblade94, post: 5049935, member: 74608"] Are there really enough people to buy into this sort of thing? We have a 3rd edition professional update already (Pathfinder), and I find many other 3rd edition clones just simple rehashes. Its like people trying to publish by including their house rules in the system core. Pretty much all of the 3rd edition clones are not worth getting as a whole. There are individual areas that they might improve, but as a whole they are not better than 3rd edition. It seems like people that still want to play D&D who were involved with 3rd edition will A) keep playing 3rd edition B) play Pathfinder or C) go to play 4e. These 3rd edition derivatives seem like alot of work put out for about 10 people. I understand wanting to do it as an intellectual exercise or for personal satisfaction, but to actually have it taken seriously as an independent game by the gamer population seems vastly unlikely. [/QUOTE]

Verification