Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="GMMichael" data-source="post: 6234908" data-attributes="member: 6685730">I got to page 11.&nbsp; Here's what I saw:What is an RPG section: great description, but your document doesn't need it.Attacker roll needs to beat defender roll: yes!&nbsp; Welcome to the post-D&amp;D gaming era.Bonuses and advantage: D&amp;D Next introduced an advantage mechanic to eliminate as many bonuses (and penalties) as possible.&nbsp; Can EAB survive without one or the other?Dice higher than d12: the 2d8 and 3d6 rolls are less-than-attractive options, given the triangular and bell curves that their outcomes resemble.&nbsp; The 3d6 should probably be 2d10, or better yet, d20.Quirks, traits, karma, stunts: I was excited about the fast, flexible, minimal rules - until I came across all of these things.And what you'll want to hear the least (sorry): there are a handful of typos by page 11 (out of 161).&nbsp; It might be time to do the dreaded line-by-line proofread again.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="GMMichael, post: 6234908, member: 6685730"] I got to page 11. Here's what I saw: What is an RPG section: great description, but your document doesn't need it. Attacker roll needs to beat defender roll: yes! Welcome to the post-D&D gaming era. Bonuses and advantage: D&D Next introduced an advantage mechanic to eliminate as many bonuses (and penalties) as possible. Can EAB survive without one or the other? Dice higher than d12: the 2d8 and 3d6 rolls are less-than-attractive options, given the triangular and bell curves that their outcomes resemble. The 3d6 should probably be 2d10, or better yet, d20. Quirks, traits, karma, stunts: I was excited about the fast, flexible, minimal rules - until I came across all of these things. And what you'll want to hear the least (sorry): there are a handful of typos by page 11 (out of 161). It might be time to do the dreaded line-by-line proofread again. [/QUOTE]

Verification