Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Enchanted Trinkets Complete--a hardcover book containing over 500 magic items for your D&D games!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="77IM" data-source="post: 4875972" data-attributes="member: 12377">Two main reasons appeal to me.1. Monster Reuse.  Monsters are only a viable threat for a very narrow range of levels.  For example, if your group is level 12 (like mine), you can disregard most monsters of level 8 or less, or level 16 or more, based purely on the hit rate.  So something like 2/3 of the Monster Manual is worthless.Removing level-bonuses to hit and AC means that damage vs. hit points is now the main difficulty factor in monsters -- essentially, a high-level monster counts like a "solo" and a low level monster counts as a "minion".  (If you adjust saving throws and save DCs to account for level, you could remove the special elite/solo rules altogether -- a solo is mostly just a higher-level monster who therefore has more hit points.)A secondary difficulty factor is special abilities; high-level monsters tend to have stuff like flying and invisibility that require high-level powers to counter.  Thus, while it may seem like PCs aren't growing over time, they really are -- by getting qualitatively better rather than quantitatively.Many video games -- which use player skill to determine whether an attack hits or misses -- use this model.  For example, the Zelda series, in which you get more damaging swords and fight guys with more hit points -- but your accuracy does not improve.  Plus, you get cool new abilities as the game progresses, not just bigger stat numbers.2.  World-Based rather than Party-Focussed challenges (i.e. "simulationism").  I run a "sandbox" campaign where there are dungeons all over the place, and the party can go wherever they want, whenever they want.  But, if the 12th-level group goes to the 1st-level dungeon, it will be a big waste of time -- why did I even bother creating the 1st-level dungeon?  If they wander into the 18th-level dungeon, they will get stomped.Removing the level-based adjustments to monsters and hazards means that the 1st-level dungeon is still relevant enough to be fun (although it will definitely be on the easy side for 12th-level damage-dealers), and the 18th-level dungeon is very difficult but not an insta-wipe (clever tactics could get them through it).A previous thread on this topic got badly derailed by people arguing against the idea.  Please, don't do that; I want to see where this thread ends up. -- 77IM</blockquote>

Verification