Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Messageboard Golem" data-source="post: 2012075" data-attributes="member: 18387">I think D&amp;DFan may have been a little too harsh on this product by giving it a 2 out of 5, considering most of his criticisms deal toward the artwork and layout.&nbsp; The content is well written, though I will concede there appear to be problems with CRs for a handful of the devils and demons presented.&nbsp; 3 out of 5 would have been more equitable, based on the content of D&amp;DFan's review.&nbsp; Regarding the artwork (b/w interior): I liked the way much of this was presented - it looked like something out of a 19th century archaeology textbook.&nbsp; Personally, I think ED&amp;D is one of the best d20 products out to-date and would give it a 4/5.&nbsp; And I don't think stats for 172 new monsters (all fiends based on various legends, mythologies and cultures from all over the globe) for $30 is unreasonable. As always, that's my opinion...</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Messageboard Golem, post: 2012075, member: 18387"] I think D&DFan may have been a little too harsh on this product by giving it a 2 out of 5, considering most of his criticisms deal toward the artwork and layout. The content is well written, though I will concede there appear to be problems with CRs for a handful of the devils and demons presented. 3 out of 5 would have been more equitable, based on the content of D&DFan's review. Regarding the artwork (b/w interior): I liked the way much of this was presented - it looked like something out of a 19th century archaeology textbook. Personally, I think ED&D is one of the best d20 products out to-date and would give it a 4/5. And I don't think stats for 172 new monsters (all fiends based on various legends, mythologies and cultures from all over the globe) for $30 is unreasonable. As always, that's my opinion... [/QUOTE]

Verification