Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="stonehead" data-source="post: 9582145" data-attributes="member: 7047885">I don't think that's true, where are you getting this information from? The ownership of a piece of artwork (and its IP) almost always goes to the one paying for it. Not to the designer nor to the artist. That's trueIf AI prompts looked like &quot;draw a curved line from point [240,312] to point [531,287] then draw...&quot; then maybe that argument could apply to AI generated images. Instead, prompts look like &quot;pretty girl, long hair, elf, beautiful background, dramatic lighting...&quot; Maybe you disagree, but to me that doesn't look like a gray area edge case at all. If such a prompt were given to a human, then there would be no question who the artist was.I mean, you can complain, but you don't get to decide what other people want to buy, nor what they want to recognize as greatness. In what world does an actor get to demand the commercial they acted in is eligible for best picture? What band has the authority to say &quot;consumers shouldn't be able to boycott my music&quot;?I don't like AI generated images, but I don't get to demand that you stop using it. Similarly, you can use AI in your product, but you don't get to demand that customers can't boycott it, nor that awards have to include it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="stonehead, post: 9582145, member: 7047885"] I don't think that's true, where are you getting this information from? The ownership of a piece of artwork (and its IP) almost always goes to the one paying for it. Not to the designer nor to the artist. That's true If AI prompts looked like "draw a curved line from point [240,312] to point [531,287] then draw..." then maybe that argument could apply to AI generated images. Instead, prompts look like "pretty girl, long hair, elf, beautiful background, dramatic lighting..." Maybe you disagree, but to me that doesn't look like a gray area edge case at all. If such a prompt were given to a human, then there would be no question who the artist was. I mean, you can complain, but you don't get to decide what other people want to buy, nor what they want to recognize as greatness. In what world does an actor get to demand the commercial they acted in is eligible for best picture? What band has the authority to say "consumers shouldn't be able to boycott my music"? I don't like AI generated images, but I don't get to demand that you stop using it. Similarly, you can use AI in your product, but you don't get to demand that customers can't boycott it, nor that awards have to include it. [/QUOTE]

Verification