Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Krug" data-source="post: 1042885" data-attributes="member: 2141">Frankly, as a voter and owner of several of the products, I find very little to complain about. I thought this year's ENnies were really well-done and everyone who won fully deserved it, and the awards were VERY competitive. Some suggestions to throw in the mix:A few cats might need to open up. Art and Presentation don't quite constitute OGL, so should they really be considered d20 awards? Not having judges would also confuse things; at least with judges you can agree on criteria for judgement. What is a setting supplement? How should it be judged etc?And yes, a book can enter any cat it wants. An excellent product is often excellent all-around. Where would Mutants and Masterminds be without the killer art?Also, best free product MUST BE original and NOT come from a larger product. The other thing might be to extend the voting period, which was a wee bit short, I found.And also a cat for Most innovative product. Why? Because I see publishers pushing the limits in various ways; electronically and more. Reward those that do.&nbsp;Overall, I think this was great, and everybody involved in it should give themselves a pat on the back.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Krug, post: 1042885, member: 2141"] Frankly, as a voter and owner of several of the products, I find very little to complain about. I thought this year's ENnies were really well-done and everyone who won fully deserved it, and the awards were VERY competitive. Some suggestions to throw in the mix: A few cats might need to open up. Art and Presentation don't quite constitute OGL, so should they really be considered d20 awards? Not having judges would also confuse things; at least with judges you can agree on criteria for judgement. What is a setting supplement? How should it be judged etc? And yes, a book can enter any cat it wants. An excellent product is often excellent all-around. Where would Mutants and Masterminds be without the killer art? Also, best free product MUST BE original and NOT come from a larger product. The other thing might be to extend the voting period, which was a wee bit short, I found. And also a cat for Most innovative product. Why? Because I see publishers pushing the limits in various ways; electronically and more. Reward those that do. Overall, I think this was great, and everybody involved in it should give themselves a pat on the back. [/QUOTE]

Verification