Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Verequus" data-source="post: 753173" data-attributes="member: 9135">I like your ideas. But you wanted also some comments <img src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f642.png" class="smilie smilie--emoji" loading="lazy" width="64" height="64" alt=":-)" title="Smile&nbsp; &nbsp; :-)"&nbsp; data-smilie="1"data-shortname=":-)" /> .1. The Alter Environment spell lists with two decriptors should be only casted with the combination of the separate spell lists, not only one of them.2. Not all elements aren't covered with Alter Environment lists.3. I thought that Alter Size could be covered with Polymorph Biomatter, but I don't know if an Outsider is Biomatter. So it's acceptable.4. Most spell lists cover only a very narrow window of effects. Dazzle is IMO a too small list and could probably an effect of another spell list (or a combination of these).5. [Element] Shield: Okay, there aren't all effects of the PH covered, but there shouldn't be a spell list inflation. The effects can be simulated through a combination Evoke [Element], Abjure [Element] (for protecting for Evoke [Element]) and Abjure [opposite Element] (for protecting against Fire, if you use Water). I don't know if one is protected against one element whether he he is more vulnerable against a attack with the opposite element but the description in the Abjure paragraph is definitely wrong.6. Light and Shadow should be special applications of the appropriate Evoke [Element] list.7. Cancel Sound and Voice Projection are special applications of the Polymorph Sound list and for messaging there exist the Telepathy lists. I don't think that the damage lists for Evoke (Area) Sound should be changed. A Sound missile is like a Force missile and deafness should be covered with the elemental side effects.P.S.: Are you from Germany?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Verequus, post: 753173, member: 9135"] I like your ideas. But you wanted also some comments :-) . 1. The Alter Environment spell lists with two decriptors should be only casted with the combination of the separate spell lists, not only one of them. 2. Not all elements aren't covered with Alter Environment lists. 3. I thought that Alter Size could be covered with Polymorph Biomatter, but I don't know if an Outsider is Biomatter. So it's acceptable. 4. Most spell lists cover only a very narrow window of effects. Dazzle is IMO a too small list and could probably an effect of another spell list (or a combination of these). 5. [Element] Shield: Okay, there aren't all effects of the PH covered, but there shouldn't be a spell list inflation. The effects can be simulated through a combination Evoke [Element], Abjure [Element] (for protecting for Evoke [Element]) and Abjure [opposite Element] (for protecting against Fire, if you use Water). I don't know if one is protected against one element whether he he is more vulnerable against a attack with the opposite element but the description in the Abjure paragraph is definitely wrong. 6. Light and Shadow should be special applications of the appropriate Evoke [Element] list. 7. Cancel Sound and Voice Projection are special applications of the Polymorph Sound list and for messaging there exist the Telepathy lists. I don't think that the damage lists for Evoke (Area) Sound should be changed. A Sound missile is like a Force missile and deafness should be covered with the elemental side effects. P.S.: Are you from Germany? [/QUOTE]

Verification