Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="candidus_cogitens" data-source="post: 502695" data-attributes="member: 770">I still think the &quot;no feat required&quot; thing is completely irrelevant and uninformative.&nbsp; But I do think you have raised an interesting point, which is that if it were not listed under Magic Items, the only other place to put it would be under Equipment, which also seems inappropriate.&nbsp; Of course, one option would have been to not list it in either place!&nbsp; But if we assume that the thing just HAD to be listed somewhere, then perhaps we should not read to much into the fact that it is found among the Magic Items--since it may be there only by default.So maybe we should look at it as a magic item that is not really to be treated as a magic item, rather than as a spell that is not to be treated like similar spells.(I kinda wish they had put it with the &quot;Superior Items&quot; in the Equipment section.&nbsp; What's wrong with having an equipment item that can be rendered useless by dispel magic?&nbsp; At least it would be clear!)I don't know.&nbsp; I might be coming around to the other side in this discussion--especially since no one seems to be joining me on the &quot;no, you can't dispel it&quot; side of the debate.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="candidus_cogitens, post: 502695, member: 770"] I still think the "no feat required" thing is completely irrelevant and uninformative. But I do think you have raised an interesting point, which is that if it were not listed under Magic Items, the only other place to put it would be under Equipment, which also seems inappropriate. Of course, one option would have been to not list it in either place! But if we assume that the thing just HAD to be listed somewhere, then perhaps we should not read to much into the fact that it is found among the Magic Items--since it may be there only by default. So maybe we should look at it as a magic item that is not really to be treated as a magic item, rather than as a spell that is not to be treated like similar spells. (I kinda wish they had put it with the "Superior Items" in the Equipment section. What's wrong with having an equipment item that can be rendered useless by dispel magic? At least it would be clear!) I don't know. I might be coming around to the other side in this discussion--especially since no one seems to be joining me on the "no, you can't dispel it" side of the debate. [/QUOTE]

Verification