Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="irdeggman" data-source="post: 3057908" data-attributes="member: 16285">My assumption was that a bard knows enough about holding his breath to know that after 3 rounds a PC is not dead (it was said that the PC assumed the dwarf was already dead after being submerged for merely 3 rounds). This is based on the fact that most of the perform skills involve controlled breathing of some kind.Since I don't know what the bard's knowledge skills or languages are then I can't assume the bard knows that dwarves are strudy (other than the fact that they look stout and strudy by the way they are built).I also can only assume that the bard has at least rudimentary knowledge of how long a character canhold their breath since I do not know what perform or knowledge skills the PC has.But the fact was that the dwarf (and apparently only the dwarf) had attempted to help the bard and then fell in while doing so.  So I have difficulty saying all these combined does not constitute an evil act.</blockquote>