Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Desdichado" data-source="post: 6380077" data-attributes="member: 2205">Great.&nbsp; As it happens, my response was crafted to answer the OP's question, though.&nbsp; My response was completely relevant to that discussion.&nbsp; Your insistence that I do so within the idiosyncratic idiom of the D&amp;D rules would be fine--I guess--if it were your question and you wanted to better bound the answers.&nbsp; As it is, I question what value of your questioning of the value of my post has to the discussion.&nbsp; Or, for that matter, what value there is in you attempting to disqualify answers that--while relevant to the OP's question--are a little bit outside of the box with regards to the default D&amp;D paradigm.Considering that the players' interpretation of alignment is the problematic issue here, making the suggestion that you can decouple alignment from the game and get exactly the results you want is not only relevant, it's central to the question.&nbsp; Your constraints on the discussion are not.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Desdichado, post: 6380077, member: 2205"] Great. As it happens, my response was crafted to answer the OP's question, though. My response was completely relevant to [I]that[/I] discussion. Your insistence that I do so within the idiosyncratic idiom of the D&D rules would be fine--I guess--if it were your question and you wanted to better bound the answers. As it is, I question what value of your questioning of the value of my post has to the discussion. Or, for that matter, what value there is in you attempting to disqualify answers that--while relevant to the OP's question--are a little bit outside of the box with regards to the default D&D paradigm. Considering that the players' interpretation of alignment is the problematic issue here, making the suggestion that you can decouple alignment from the game and get exactly the results you want is not only relevant, it's [B]central[/B] to the question. Your constraints on the discussion are not. [/QUOTE]

Verification