Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Jedi_Solo" data-source="post: 4224480" data-attributes="member: 40245">I liked what I saw here.There is no way I would want to have a three tier setup for the rules.&nbsp; Then you need to have all three tiers listed for (practically) everything in the game.HP:&nbsp; Always Max, Average, Roll ItMagic: High, Medium, LowItem Use: All At Will, Average, All 1/dayItem Id: 5 Minutes, 100gp + 1 hour, 100gp + 8 hoursThen, the house rules document would have to have a listing of what was used for everything.&nbsp; Sure, it would be easy for DMs to say &quot;All Moderate&quot; or &quot;All Hard&quot; but you know that isn't how it would turn out in practice.There is no way I could remember the we would be using the Max HP but the long ID times and the Moderate This and the Easy That and the Hard Other Thing.&nbsp; I'd need them all written down and would greatly extend the House Rules sheet for our group.&nbsp; It is much easier to say All As Written except for X, Y and Z.And I'm a player in our group - not the DM.&nbsp; I have no problem with House Rules and being told &quot;No&quot; at the start of a campaign.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Jedi_Solo, post: 4224480, member: 40245"] I liked what I saw here. There is no way I would want to have a three tier setup for the rules. Then you need to have all three tiers listed for (practically) everything in the game. HP: Always Max, Average, Roll It Magic: High, Medium, Low Item Use: All At Will, Average, All 1/day Item Id: 5 Minutes, 100gp + 1 hour, 100gp + 8 hours Then, the house rules document would have to have a listing of what was used for everything. Sure, it would be easy for DMs to say "All Moderate" or "All Hard" but you know that isn't how it would turn out in practice. There is no way I could remember the we would be using the Max HP but the long ID times and the Moderate This and the Easy That and the Hard Other Thing. I'd need them all written down and would greatly extend the House Rules sheet for our group. It is much easier to say All As Written except for X, Y and Z. And I'm a player in our group - not the DM. I have no problem with House Rules and being told "No" at the start of a campaign. [/QUOTE]

Verification