Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Kahuna Burger" data-source="post: 3976021" data-attributes="member: 8439">Not a critical fumble person here either. As others have pointed out, the balance argument isn't compelling because crits are balanced already by enemy crits. Additionally, unless you are using special houserules for crits, there isn't that reasonable a comparison. If your crits can cause your enemy to be automaticly disarmed with no opposed check, tripped in the same way or sunder his weapon regardless of hardness (or magicly heal you the amount of your weapon damage), the critical misses are balanced. Otherwise, doing the thing you are trying to do very well is not balanced by failing at what you are trying to do and having a disaster on top of it.And unless it's a very unusual game, I don't like slapstick comedy in my combat.</blockquote>