Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mort" data-source="post: 3251100" data-attributes="member: 762">If we are going to get into semantics: Extra spell says you can &quot;learn&quot; an extra spell. You can only cast spells from your allowed spell list - so whether extra spell allows a spell of your list is irrelevant because you can't cast it. Note both the warmage (CA) and begauiler (PHB II) with their respective special abilities, say you can &quot;add a spell to your existing list&quot;, which is very different language and should be the language looked at. Because the feat is in the same book as the warmage, yet does not expressly allow adding the spell to your class spell list, that implies it does not. The FAQ merely clarifies this.Regardless - think of it this way. Not allowing a spell off your class list with this feat is clear simple and does not lead to any complications.&nbsp; Allowing a spell off your class list, leads to all sorts of questions and rules problems. Even if it was ambiguous, simpler is usually better.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mort, post: 3251100, member: 762"] If we are going to get into semantics: Extra spell says you can "learn" an extra spell. You can only cast spells from your allowed spell list - so whether extra spell allows a spell of your list is irrelevant because you can't cast it. Note both the warmage (CA) and begauiler (PHB II) with their respective special abilities, say you can "add a spell to your existing list", which is very different language and should be the language looked at. Because the feat is in the same book as the warmage, yet does not expressly allow adding the spell to your class spell list, that implies it does not. The FAQ merely clarifies this. Regardless - think of it this way. Not allowing a spell off your class list with this feat is clear simple and does not lead to any complications. Allowing a spell off your class list, leads to all sorts of questions and rules problems. Even if it was ambiguous, simpler is usually better. [/QUOTE]

Verification