Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mort" data-source="post: 3251647" data-attributes="member: 762">There is a huge difference between the wording of expanded knowledge and the wording of extra spell, which actually argues against extra spell allowing a caster to choose off list spells. First expanded power uses the term &quot;add&quot; - the same as the warmage and beguiler abilities - but not the &quot;learn&quot; language from extra spell.Much more importantly, expanded knowledge explicitly states &quot;You can choose any power, including powers from another discipline's list or even another class's list.&quot; Extra spell has no such wording. As a matter of fact, all abilities I can find that let you go &quot;off list&quot; explicitly state that they allow this; extra spell does not. I don't see as much ambiguity as other people here (though there really isn't that much as there is close to 90% agreement and that's remarkable for the rules forum on a disputed topic).</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mort, post: 3251647, member: 762"] There is a huge difference between the wording of expanded knowledge and the wording of extra spell, which actually argues against extra spell allowing a caster to choose off list spells. First expanded power uses the term "add" - the same as the warmage and beguiler abilities - but not the "learn" language from extra spell. Much more importantly, expanded knowledge explicitly states "You can choose any power, including powers from another discipline's list or even another class's list." Extra spell has no such wording. As a matter of fact, all abilities I can find that let you go "off list" explicitly state that they allow this; extra spell does not. I don't see as much ambiguity as other people here (though there really isn't that much as there is close to 90% agreement and that's remarkable for the rules forum on a disputed topic). [/QUOTE]

Verification