Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Thia Halmades" data-source="post: 2626733" data-attributes="member: 35863">And again, my point is as much how it works as to why it works.&nbsp; RAW says that Slay Living and F2S are 5th, but you can't generate permanent wealth until 7th at Limited Wish.&nbsp; And, as I said, if it were me I wouldn't do it, but as a campaign specific spell, hey, go nuts.&nbsp; We're talking my opinion, not my ruling.&nbsp; I'd make it 5th level and call it good, 6th if I were feeling cranky.&nbsp; The whole solid-gold thing bothers me.&nbsp; Again, I submit the argument that you can't &quot;make gold&quot;, but I will also yield that by the time you're turning Fey into lawn ornaments you don't need it, point taken and conceded.&nbsp; If you want to balance it, in my opinion, 5th is probably sufficient.&nbsp; However, limited target and extensive duration (two counter points) could make an argument for fourth.And I stand by what I said originally; it just doesn't seem terribly balanced in my head, although I'll yield that similar spells exist as touch attacks and instants.&nbsp; Ultimately, house spell, house flavor.&nbsp; If the question is: Will this break anything?&nbsp; Answer: No.LCpt. Thia Halmades</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Thia Halmades, post: 2626733, member: 35863"] And again, my point is as much how it works as to why it works. RAW says that Slay Living and F2S are 5th, but you can't generate permanent wealth until 7th at Limited Wish. And, as I said, if it were me I wouldn't do it, but as a campaign specific spell, hey, go nuts. We're talking my opinion, not my ruling. I'd make it 5th level and call it good, 6th if I were feeling cranky. The whole solid-gold thing bothers me. Again, I submit the argument that you can't "make gold", but I will also yield that by the time you're turning Fey into lawn ornaments you don't need it, point taken and conceded. If you want to balance it, in my opinion, 5th is probably sufficient. However, limited target and extensive duration (two counter points) could make an argument for fourth. And I stand by what I said originally; it just doesn't seem terribly balanced in my head, although I'll yield that similar spells exist as touch attacks and instants. Ultimately, house spell, house flavor. If the question is: Will this break anything? Answer: No. LCpt. Thia Halmades [/QUOTE]

Verification