Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Steel_Wind" data-source="post: 5700194" data-attributes="member: 20741">Hmm. I see what you are getting at. I think the word "favorite" is too strong. I think what you are trying to ask is whether or not a module is well designed, we still have a great deal of affection for the module just the same.I can admit to this, mainly as my affections were bestowed upon a module at an earlier point in my gaming "career". Such that while the practicalities of a module's design have not stood the test of time -- my affections for it, out of nostalgia or other reasons endure.DL1: Dragons of Despair: Hickman's classic  -- if not iconic module -- is a very heavy handed overt railroad designed at a time when the way to steer players towards a goal in a metaplot based adventure arc were not yet known and handled VERY poorly. I still have great affection for the module though, notwithstanding its deep flaws. Tegel Manor: Tegel Manor is a "classic" dungeon where the map doesn't make sense, the denizens of Tegel Manor make ZERO sense and the entire thing is a preposterous setting filled with even more preposterous creatures, most of whom wait in their hermetically sealed rooms until activated by another adventuring PC. Tegel Manor is a wholly SILLY PLACE.I still have great affection for Tegel Manor just the same.  In terms of a modern design? It's total suckage. Yet my nostalgia for Tegel Manor overwhelms those rational, design-based objections.At the same time, I don't have those feelings of nostalgia to rescue B1 or B2 from the dungheap (they are both CRAP folks), and the original ToEE is mostly substandard as well when viewed from a modern design perspective. Sorry folks -- there it is. That doesn't mean you're wong for liking it though. Affection is not required to be rational!Generally, I think modules need to be assessed in accordance with the times and systems for which each was created, when they were created. They are a "snapshot in time" in many respects.My favorite modules, however, meet the "superior design" evaluation test.Erik Mona's "The  Whispering Cairn" from the Age of Worms AP is a clinic on dungeon design. Similarly, Richard Pett's Six-Fold Trial, vol II of the Council of Thieves AP is probably the single finest issue of Pathfinder Adventure Path yet published. These are my favorites and they are both exremely well crafted adventures.In twenty years? I suppose it is possible I will have a different view -- though I doubt that the underlying soundness of the design of either will need any reassessment.</blockquote>

Verification