Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="5ekyu" data-source="post: 7357631" data-attributes="member: 6919838">But i still do not get the premise.Where do you draw the conclusion that GMs would out of thin air with really no other in-game references allow an inspiring chat with a good CHA check to provide temporary hit points to say everone without a bigger innervate *without* a feature adding that notion at all into the game?Where do you draw the conclusion that this &quot;chat for THP&quot; would be dreamed up and applied in play by,more GMs and players than use the feats that do this? The premise is that the feats providing mechanics and those ideas - even without mandating &quot;only way is thru feat&quot; -&nbsp; reduces or results in less use of things like this in play, right? So before 5e provided this feat, how many times did you see GMs winging CHA chats restoring or granting HP in play? It must have been lotsa times right, if it was one chosen to highlight this reduction in in-play options after it is defined and provided as a option for many characters? Have you seen that done hundreds of times? I have been playing for more than a little bit and i never once saw a GM or a player wing CHA chats into THP or HP once, and thats with hearing lotsa of wild ideas over time.Cannot imagine how many times you musta seen it. Care to share?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="5ekyu, post: 7357631, member: 6919838"] But i still do not get the premise. Where do you draw the conclusion that GMs would out of thin air with really no other in-game references allow an inspiring chat with a good CHA check to provide temporary hit points to say everone without a bigger innervate *without* a feature adding that notion at all into the game? Where do you draw the conclusion that this "chat for THP" would be dreamed up and applied in play by,more GMs and players than use the feats that do this? The premise is that the feats providing mechanics and those ideas - even without mandating "only way is thru feat" - reduces or results in less use of things like this in play, right? So before 5e provided this feat, how many times did you see GMs winging CHA chats restoring or granting HP in play? It must have been lotsa times right, if it was one chosen to highlight this reduction in in-play options after it is defined and provided as a option for many characters? Have you seen that done hundreds of times? I have been playing for more than a little bit and i never once saw a GM or a player wing CHA chats into THP or HP once, and thats with hearing lotsa of wild ideas over time. Cannot imagine how many times you musta seen it. Care to share? [/QUOTE]

Verification