NOW LIVE! Today's the day you meet your new best friend. You don’t have to leave Wolfy behind... In 'Pets & Sidekicks' your companions level up with you!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Dlsharrock" data-source="post: 4268343" data-attributes="member: 55833">I don't know what a 'pseudo in character aside' is. To my mind it was an OOC comment directed at Lucean. In-character comments should be made in-character. Out of character comments should be made out of character. The guidelines clearly state you should mark OOC comments OOC so there's no misunderstanding. There is no PICA option.I can't find any evidence of an OOC question from Lucean concerning how Cara found out about the group. None of which explains why you attempted to discern IC details using a critical comment later in the game, so my opinion remains unchanged.EDIT: I forgot to comment on this part, sorry:Actually I disagree. I think it would have been most acceptable. Far more appropriate than posting an OOC comment to the player. But again, this merely suggests to me that you're having difficulting defining the difference between what the character thinks and what the player thinks. The two are mutually exclusive, which is the whole point of IC and OOC.I've politely advised Lucean against commenting, precisely because of his proximity to the issue. If you'd like to rephrase your question to him in the IC thread when/if we've resolved this, Dire Lemming, I encourage you to do so in a way that makes your intentions clearer so that you have a better understanding of what Adam knows about Philip's personality. The fact remains, *I*, as moderator of this game, have taken issue with the comments, not Lucean. Effectively, it has nothing to do with him and he shouldn't feel obliged in any way shape or form to get involved if he doesn't want to.Crucially: we would be having the same discussion had you directed your comment at greenstar or Kookalouris. Indeed I'd have taken issue with any player who made the comment in question. That said, if Lucean feels strongly about commenting, I certainly won't censor him from doing so, particularly as Kookalouris and greenstar have both commented. Though nothing Lucean says will change my standpoint, especially considering I have already sought eleven objective opinions.More relevantly, you haven't explained how I have misinterpreted your comments, nor (more importantly AFAIC) agreed to either of my requests. My assumption can only be that you have no interest in a resolution.</blockquote>

Verification