Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="N'raac" data-source="post: 6201581" data-attributes="member: 6681948">Nowhere does it say he CASTS wishes.&nbsp; It says he grants them, and he is capable of doing so only when captured.&nbsp; As I note above, you could command him to allow himself to be captured, but remaining captured is not an immediate service, and I doubt too many Noble Djinn can't figure out what comes after being captured.Does he need to travel in between?&nbsp; &quot;Fighting for you in a single battle&quot; is one service.&nbsp; If those three mooks are in one battle, in which you are engaged, immediate service.&nbsp; If not, you are asking him to hunt down and kill three separate targets, which is three tasks (none of which strikes me as &quot;immediate&quot;).Once again, you take the interpretation which carries an overpowered result, and then complain that the wizard is overpowered as a consequence.&nbsp; It does matter - there is nothing in the rules which says a Noble Djinn can grant wishes if he is not captured.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="N'raac, post: 6201581, member: 6681948"] Nowhere does it say he CASTS wishes. It says he grants them, and he is capable of doing so only when captured. As I note above, you could command him to allow himself to be captured, but remaining captured is not an immediate service, and I doubt too many Noble Djinn can't figure out what comes after being captured. Does he need to travel in between? "Fighting for you in a single battle" is one service. If those three mooks are in one battle, in which you are engaged, immediate service. If not, you are asking him to hunt down and kill three separate targets, which is three tasks (none of which strikes me as "immediate"). Once again, you take the interpretation which carries an overpowered result, and then complain that the wizard is overpowered as a consequence. It does matter - there is nothing in the rules which says a Noble Djinn can grant wishes if he is not captured. [/QUOTE]

Verification