Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Raven Crowking" data-source="post: 3824458" data-attributes="member: 18280">Actually, as I recall, you thought another one had anime characteristics.&nbsp; Long ago, I suggested that you need an impartial judge.&nbsp; Specific impartial judges might gain a consensus.&nbsp; Consensus from everyone, though?&nbsp; Unlikely on anything.&nbsp;&nbsp; This is the Interweb.&nbsp; If I said the sky was blue, I'd have an argument on my hands.We've seen Warforged + original anime art Warforged look was designed from.We've seen BESM gnome on stool, which you (if you are the judge) said qualified.&nbsp; And, before you say &quot;but others didn't agree&quot;, I must say, &quot;then why did others not agreeing matter when you said something was not anime-ish?&quot;We've seen Manga Tiefling.&nbsp; Which you (if you are the judge) said qualified.We've seen many other images in which there has been consensus (if not absolute concensus).I certainly agree that I am not an impartial judge, but I suggest again that you appoint one or more.....and not simply on the basis that they are anime naysayers.&nbsp; The mods here on EN World do a wonderful job of being impartial (IMHO).&nbsp; Why not get Piratecat to judge?BTW, how can you sayEvery &quot;anime inspired&quot; bit we've seen so far comes from Eberron artwork AFAIK. Is it fair to say that Eberron, with it specific styles, may have anime influences that are more pronounced than the rest of the game?if you believe that there was only one bit of &quot;anime inspired&quot; art and it was from FR?&nbsp; What are the Eberron pieces that qualify then?RC</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Raven Crowking, post: 3824458, member: 18280"] Actually, as I recall, you thought another one had anime characteristics. Long ago, I suggested that you need an impartial judge. Specific impartial judges might gain a consensus. Consensus from everyone, though? Unlikely on anything. This is the Interweb. If I said the sky was blue, I'd have an argument on my hands. We've seen Warforged + original anime art Warforged look was designed from. We've seen BESM gnome on stool, which you (if you are the judge) said qualified. And, before you say "but others didn't agree", I must say, "then why did others not agreeing matter when you said something was [i]not[/i] anime-ish?" We've seen Manga Tiefling. Which you (if you are the judge) said qualified. We've seen many other images in which there has been consensus (if not absolute concensus). I certainly agree that I am not an impartial judge, but I suggest again that you appoint one or more.....and not simply on the basis that they are anime naysayers. The mods here on EN World do a wonderful job of being impartial (IMHO). Why not get Piratecat to judge? BTW, how can you say [indent]Every "anime inspired" bit we've seen so far comes from Eberron artwork AFAIK. Is it fair to say that Eberron, with it specific styles, may have anime influences that are more pronounced than the rest of the game?[/indent] if you believe that there was only one bit of "anime inspired" art and it was from FR? What are the Eberron pieces that qualify then? RC [/QUOTE]

Verification