Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Minicol" data-source="post: 4466699" data-attributes="member: 17308">Thank you for your kind answers.I'll try to answer as best :1 Sure, you are right. But a new (or returning) player picking up the book will know about the nuking and expect it to have happened. May make communication around the game table harder.2 Actually this is good news. I did not read that article before. I could even buy that (those ?) new world if it is good and inspiring. Yes, really, not kidding about that.3 I was judging from the reactions seen on this forum (and others). plenty of people seem to have been alienated. I felt this too, though not as bad as others. To be clear, it's due to how it was nuked, rather than the nuking itself.4 Yes : you are right. But essentially same as 1 : a new player with the book in end is disappointed/surprised/ ... that is book is not not as useful in your campaign as in any &quot;standard&quot; campaign. And might drop out because of that.But mostly : I have the feeling that 4e would be best served by something really built for it. We could talk about the new coolness, rather than this debate.Regards and goodnight anyways.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Minicol, post: 4466699, member: 17308"] Thank you for your kind answers. I'll try to answer as best : 1 Sure, you are right. But a new (or returning) player picking up the book will know about the nuking and expect it to have happened. May make communication around the game table harder. 2 Actually this is good news. I did not read that article before. I could even buy that (those ?) new world if it is good and inspiring. Yes, really, not kidding about that. 3 I was judging from the reactions seen on this forum (and others). plenty of people seem to have been alienated. I felt this too, though not as bad as others. To be clear, it's due to how it was nuked, rather than the nuking itself. 4 Yes : you are right. But essentially same as 1 : a new player with the book in end is disappointed/surprised/ ... that is book is not not as useful in your campaign as in any "standard" campaign. And might drop out because of that. But mostly : I have the feeling that 4e would be best served by something really built for it. We could talk about the new coolness, rather than this debate. Regards and goodnight anyways. [/QUOTE]

Verification