Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="fido_usernameinuse" data-source="post: 1205147" data-attributes="member: 15083">Ahh a challenge...The flawed word here is "require". What you require is subjective, and thus subject to interpretation.A victim of this geas would thus have to accompany the caster until such time that he deems his interference is required.When this happens the victim is released from his service (since the wording of the geas doesn't specify that the victim should continue to assist him after he has given his aid.).The caster specifically requesting aid at a given time would not necessarily lead to him receiving any (at that time) because the victim might think the caster could manage on his own.OT:Another potentially difficult word is maximum, or rather maximum benefit, because (not knowing the future) there is no way to know what would benefit the caster the most. Conclusion:Geas in it's present state sucks badly, houserules is required (or a DM's judging). I find that defining each geas specifically opens for too much contention(?) and rules-lawyering.</blockquote>