Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Guest 6801328" data-source="post: 6868189">Max, Max, Max....We've gone over this.&nbsp; But let's do it yet again.&nbsp; I believe you are referring to the quotes on page 177 of the PHB:(If you have more &quot;rules&quot; in mind, please share them.)Please note those &quot;rules&quot; don't actually specify what the relationship is between the Intelligence score and those tasks/abilities/aptitudes.&nbsp; Just that &quot;Intelligence measures them&quot; and &quot;an Intelligence check comes into play&quot;.Well, the type of roleplaying I'm talking about fully complies with both of those requirements.&nbsp; I'm measuring mental acuity, etc., by making an Intelligence check (or a check of an Int skill).&nbsp; Likewise an Intelligence check does come into play when my characters need to draw on logic et. al.&nbsp; So exactly what rule am I breaking?I'd still argue that those aren't rules because they aren't specific enough to be rules, as this little exercise between us pals has revealed.&nbsp; But, hey, if you think they're rules, I'm still in compliance.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Guest 6801328, post: 6868189"] Max, Max, Max.... We've gone over this. But let's do it yet again. I believe you are referring to the quotes on page 177 of the PHB: (If you have more "rules" in mind, please share them.) Please note those "rules" don't actually specify what the relationship is between the Intelligence score and those tasks/abilities/aptitudes. Just that "Intelligence measures them" and "an Intelligence check comes into play". Well, the type of roleplaying I'm talking about fully complies with both of those requirements. I'm measuring mental acuity, etc., by making an Intelligence check (or a check of an Int skill). Likewise an Intelligence check does come into play when my characters need to draw on logic et. al. So exactly what rule am I breaking? I'd still argue that those aren't rules because they aren't specific enough to be rules, as this little exercise between us pals has revealed. But, hey, if you think they're rules, I'm still in compliance. [/QUOTE]

Verification