Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="p_johnston" data-source="post: 8909541" data-attributes="member: 7016849">A) I do prefer variable damage if for no other reason then to give my less used dice their weekly workouts. The poor D12 needs to occasionally see sunshine also.B) are you kidding? If trees screamed all the time I would be more likely to cut the leafy leafers down!C) So I do like this idea. 13th age does something kinda similar where each class does different damage with different classes of weapons. So a barbarian with a dagger does 1d4 but a rogue with a dagger does 1d8. It also had weapons divided into groups instead of just listing each and every one. I really enjoyed having it be a bit more freeform where players were able to pick whatever weapon fit the character instead of having 6 rapiers in the party because it's the only d8 dex weapon. Honestly I think that you could simplify things to the questions of One Vs Two handed and Melee Vs Range and just have each class do different damage depending on which square the weapon lands in. The Dex Ranger wants to use a club instead of a rapier? Sure. The Barbarian wants to wield an uprooted small tree instead of a greataxe? Have at it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="p_johnston, post: 8909541, member: 7016849"] A) I do prefer variable damage if for no other reason then to give my less used dice their weekly workouts. The poor D12 needs to occasionally see sunshine also. B) are you kidding? If trees screamed all the time I would be more likely to cut the leafy leafers down! C) So I do like this idea. 13th age does something kinda similar where each class does different damage with different classes of weapons. So a barbarian with a dagger does 1d4 but a rogue with a dagger does 1d8. It also had weapons divided into groups instead of just listing each and every one. I really enjoyed having it be a bit more freeform where players were able to pick whatever weapon fit the character instead of having 6 rapiers in the party because it's the only d8 dex weapon. Honestly I think that you could simplify things to the questions of One Vs Two handed and Melee Vs Range and just have each class do different damage depending on which square the weapon lands in. The Dex Ranger wants to use a club instead of a rapier? Sure. The Barbarian wants to wield an uprooted small tree instead of a greataxe? Have at it. [/QUOTE]

Verification