Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Andor" data-source="post: 3539722" data-attributes="member: 1879">I didn't say it did, just that it was a good act. One good act does not undo a lifetime of evil, unless of course you are Anakin Skywalker...That having been said Jack of the first movie is not particularly evil. He is entirely self motivated to be sure, but he's not cruel, he doesn't kill the helpless, he doesn't even betray a trust (if you squint a bit). I would pin Jack of the first movie a N possibly even with good tendancies. Will thinks he's good, and Will is so LG he's practically a paladin.In the second movie it's a bit of a different story. He betrays anyone and everyone out of pure self interest. Amd selling Will soul to Davy Jones is certainly evil, although it's worth noting that was the contingency plan and not the ideal outcome. So he's certainly willing to commit evil acts. He does however have one mitigating circumstance, he's terrified out of his wits. We know from the first movie he is driven by a patholgical love of freedom, and now he faces eternal slavery. So there is the open question of how much leeway one gets on the alignment chart for roleplaying fear.</blockquote>