Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="ruleslawyer" data-source="post: 3539915" data-attributes="member: 1757">I'd say it's even more complicated than that.Jack never gives up the quest for Jones's heart, so who's to say he has any intention of honoring any bargain with Jones? The entire bit with the lost-soul sad-sack crewmen could just be a stalling tactic while he figures out how to get the heart (as he does the minute he finds Elizabeth). If Jack were truly evil, there's not much stopping him from just ferrying a bunch of no-hopers to Jones and having done at that.I'd say Jack is practically the embodiment of CN, as it's impossible to really say whether what he's doing is *genuinely* evil, *genuinely* heroic, simply crazy, or a massive fake-out on all counts.</blockquote>