Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Neonchameleon" data-source="post: 8620998" data-attributes="member: 87792">As I have pointed out this isn't true. The comment you were replying to and outright quoted explicitly says that they took a short rest in ten minutes by means of the Catnap spell.Your punishment also says &quot;You rest and your rest is uneventful, and plagued by bad dreams. It has no effect.&quot; And the only &quot;It&quot; that could be referred to to have no effect is the rest. Which means that you yourself wrote that the DM was arbitrarily altering the rules to deny the effect of the rest as well as everything else. This is arbitrary punishment no matter how you look at it.But the doom clock was added by you retroactively. And then jumped forward eight hours in the space of ten minutes.An adult would have asked &quot;are you sure you want to take 8 hours of rest? You do know the BBEG will do things in that time?&quot; Discussing things that the players would be aware of. And would have had the response &quot;No, we're taking ten minutes of rest&quot;.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Neonchameleon, post: 8620998, member: 87792"] As I have pointed out this isn't true. The comment you were replying to and outright quoted [I]explicitly[/I] says that they took a short rest [I]in ten minutes[/I] by means of the Catnap spell. Your punishment [I]also[/I] says [I]"You rest and your rest is uneventful, and plagued by bad dreams. It has no effect."[/I] And the only "It" that could be referred to to have no effect is the rest. Which means that you yourself wrote that the DM was arbitrarily altering the rules to deny the effect of the rest as well as everything else. This is arbitrary punishment no matter how you look at it. But the doom clock was added by you retroactively. And then jumped forward eight hours in the space of ten minutes. An adult would have asked "are you sure you want to take 8 hours of rest? You do know the BBEG will do things in that time?" Discussing things that the players would be aware of. And would have had the response "No, we're taking ten minutes of rest". [/QUOTE]

Verification