Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Prism" data-source="post: 5022652" data-attributes="member: 9501">For me its the sheer amount of adventures from previous editions that allows us choice. I had great fun playing and running many modules from these editions but there were plenty more that we didn't bother with. Tomb of horrors I would say has an ok concept but great execution for what it does best - a tournament style moduleVeiled Society has a great concept but slightly lacking excecution - even the DM has to work hard to understand what is supposed to happenRavenloft - great concept and execution. An awesome example of great module designRed Hand of Doom - again great concept and a very well designed mini campaignThe first three 4e adventures (before we gave up on the modules). The problem for me is very poor concept. There is little to nothing original in the story. In fact I barely remember much of a story. The execution is ok. Good in parts and silly in others.For me it took 3e about 2 years before some decent Wotc adventures began to appear. I'm not to worried yet but hopefully at some point a 4e module with a good and interesting concept will come out. There's no reason it can't be done. Red Hand would play wonderfully in 4e I'm sure. The 4e classic adventure just hasn't happened yet. Some dungeon modules have looked good thoughHaving said all that, the ability for 4e to deal with quick conversions from older systems is great</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Prism, post: 5022652, member: 9501"] For me its the sheer amount of adventures from previous editions that allows us choice. I had great fun playing and running many modules from these editions but there were plenty more that we didn't bother with. Tomb of horrors I would say has an ok concept but great execution for what it does best - a tournament style module Veiled Society has a great concept but slightly lacking excecution - even the DM has to work hard to understand what is supposed to happen Ravenloft - great concept and execution. An awesome example of great module design Red Hand of Doom - again great concept and a very well designed mini campaign The first three 4e adventures (before we gave up on the modules). The problem for me is very poor concept. There is little to nothing original in the story. In fact I barely remember much of a story. The execution is ok. Good in parts and silly in others. For me it took 3e about 2 years before some decent Wotc adventures began to appear. I'm not to worried yet but hopefully at some point a 4e module with a good and interesting concept will come out. There's no reason it can't be done. Red Hand would play wonderfully in 4e I'm sure. The 4e classic adventure just hasn't happened yet. Some dungeon modules have looked good though Having said all that, the ability for 4e to deal with quick conversions from older systems is great [/QUOTE]

Verification