Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Paul Farquhar" data-source="post: 8081020" data-attributes="member: 6906155">Theros, Ravnica, and Eberron all have setting specific rules. e.g. Dragonmarks cannot work the same way in 5e as 3e.Theros and Ravnica are new settings, there is no fluff from previous editions.SCAG is pretty useless, I make more use of my 3rd edition FR book and FR Wiki.If there are rules for it then it would need adapting. So that's one thing so far.Now you are talking about something completely different. That's not adapting, that's advancing the timeline. And whether or not to do that is extremely controversial. Many Greyhawk fans do not like later additions to the setting, and would rather the timeline be reset, which is what ERFTLW does, and what GoS seems to do.You might not be a purist, but many Greyhawk fans are. Who should WotC try to please? The Greyhawk fans who want to keep the later stuff, or those who would prefer the clock to be reset? Who is right?</blockquote>