Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Zardnaar" data-source="post: 7804867" data-attributes="member: 6716779">Dragonborn sucked in 3E as well, never allowed them.Another reason for the 1983 is a lot if the settings have been ruined by TSR metaplot.Say you made a new GH and set it at the 83 boxed set. You can still add anything to it that came after.If you set it later and try removing something there's always that one player who goes but the boxed set say.......Imagine if they did Nerath but cut Tieflings and Dragonborn. How many kitchen sink settings do you need, Nerath, FR, Eberron and Greyhawk?Ravnica for example is a modern setting without a few phb races.Why Tieflings over Dragonbon? Tiefling at least make sense because of Iuz. Drow exist as well.Dragonborn could be replaced with any other race there's nothing really special or logical to them to tie them to Greyhawk.You could make up some nation I suppose over the sea or whatever but you could add any race that way.Adding Yuan Ti from VGtM makes more sense for ecample.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Zardnaar, post: 7804867, member: 6716779"] Dragonborn sucked in 3E as well, never allowed them. Another reason for the 1983 is a lot if the settings have been ruined by TSR metaplot. Say you made a new GH and set it at the 83 boxed set. You can still add anything to it that came after. If you set it later and try removing something there's always that one player who goes but the boxed set say....... Imagine if they did Nerath but cut Tieflings and Dragonborn. How many kitchen sink settings do you need, Nerath, FR, Eberron and Greyhawk? Ravnica for example is a modern setting without a few phb races. Why Tieflings over Dragonbon? Tiefling at least make sense because of Iuz. Drow exist as well. Dragonborn could be replaced with any other race there's nothing really special or logical to them to tie them to Greyhawk. You could make up some nation I suppose over the sea or whatever but you could add any race that way. Adding Yuan Ti from VGtM makes more sense for ecample. [/QUOTE]

Verification