Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Coroc" data-source="post: 7805355" data-attributes="member: 6895991">Ok, but then we are arguing about taste, not systematic or rules baseline. And the thing is that no one seems to care about not all base and optional phb races being in the ravnica setting, which would be probably because they did not want to alter the tone of the setting.Otoh it seems to be of utmost importance that a possible greyhawk 5e has to be streamlined to the 5e fluff defined by the phb, even the optional. There the tone is not important to the same people.So that's the thing greyhawk and ravnica explicitely do not have in common but they should, no matter if you personally think it matters or not.&nbsp; Some guy here on the forum asked for a different game system for darksun because in his opinion it could never be made compatible to 5e.Since we are arguing about taste aka fluff and not rules I can&nbsp; argue I do not like the distinctive tone and taste a PC dragonborn would have for me in some official 5e greyhawk product, and if I would buy the product I would mod dragonborn out&nbsp; of it, and if this would not be possible for whatever reason I would not buy it. If this is the better argument for you, and weighs in more heavily than a clean analysis then be it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Coroc, post: 7805355, member: 6895991"] Ok, but then we are arguing about taste, not systematic or rules baseline. And the thing is that no one seems to care about not all base and optional phb races being in the ravnica setting, which would be probably because they did not want to alter the tone of the setting. Otoh it seems to be of utmost importance that a possible greyhawk 5e has to be streamlined to the 5e fluff defined by the phb, even the optional. There the tone is not important to the same people. So that's the thing greyhawk and ravnica explicitely do not have in common but they should, no matter if you personally think it matters or not. Some guy here on the forum asked for a different game system for darksun because in his opinion it could never be made compatible to 5e. Since we are arguing about taste aka fluff and not rules I can argue I do not like the distinctive tone and taste a PC dragonborn would have for me in some official 5e greyhawk product, and if I would buy the product I would mod dragonborn out of it, and if this would not be possible for whatever reason I would not buy it. If this is the better argument for you, and weighs in more heavily than a clean analysis then be it. [/QUOTE]

Verification