Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="LokiDR" data-source="post: 873413" data-attributes="member: 6239">Can a magic immune creature walk through a wall of force?Can a magic immune creature ignore a maze spell?Does a magic immune creature get damaged by a transmute stone to mud on the cavern ceiling above them?It seems the rules are scarce here.&nbsp; I find nothing in the Monster FAQ about what exactly is affected by Magic Immunity.&nbsp; So we are left with supposition.&nbsp; If your answer to the above 3 questions was &quot;no&quot;, then you make the assumption that magic immunity is completely unrelated to Spell Resistance.&nbsp; I take the opposite approach.&nbsp; If a spell doesn't allow for SR, then your magic immunity doesn't protect you from it.Riddle me this, if you would: if a creature is immune to all magic, why is that magic is needed to hit it?&nbsp; We are talking about creatures that all have DR.&nbsp; Does that make sense to you, because it doesn't to me.Artoomis, you want a nice simple answer.&nbsp; There isn't one.&nbsp; I would say &quot;completely resist&quot; can imply active resistance.&nbsp; I would say that the abilities Spell Immunity and Magic Immunity are different, but related.&nbsp; If there is a question about magic bringing about some effect that might affect a golem, I will defer to previous rulings on SR for consistancy.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="LokiDR, post: 873413, member: 6239"] Can a magic immune creature walk through a wall of force? Can a magic immune creature ignore a maze spell? Does a magic immune creature get damaged by a transmute stone to mud on the cavern ceiling above them? It seems the rules are scarce here. I find nothing in the Monster FAQ about what exactly is affected by Magic Immunity. So we are left with supposition. If your answer to the above 3 questions was "no", then you make the assumption that magic immunity is completely unrelated to Spell Resistance. I take the opposite approach. If a spell doesn't allow for SR, then your magic immunity doesn't protect you from it. Riddle me this, if you would: if a creature is immune to all magic, why is that magic is needed to hit it? We are talking about creatures that all have DR. Does that make sense to you, because it doesn't to me. Artoomis, you want a nice simple answer. There isn't one. I would say "completely resist" can imply active resistance. I would say that the abilities Spell Immunity and Magic Immunity are different, but related. If there is a question about magic bringing about some effect that might affect a golem, I will defer to previous rulings on SR for consistancy. [/QUOTE]

Verification