Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Xath" data-source="post: 2421019" data-attributes="member: 17040">As much as I despise Snape right now, a part of me is pretty sure he's not evil.  I was always ready to side with Harry when he said Snape was evil in the other books, but this time I have my doubts.Remember how Nearly Headless Nick said that Snape and Dumbledore had had an arguement?  Snape had said that he didn't want to do it anymore and Dumbledore told him that he had to.  I think Snape completed the Unbreakable Vow under orders from Dumbledore.  Harry had suspected Malfoy of doing plenty of evil things, and had informed Dumbledore.  But none of the evidence Harry had given was enough to prove to Dumbledore that Malfoy had been behind the previous attacks.  Dumbledore had to have been learning from Snape.  He didn't know the whole story because Malfoy wasn't telling Snape everything.Also, I don't think Malfoy is going to become completely evil.  It was proven in this book that the only reason that Malfoy was fighting for Voldemort was out of the love he has for his mother (and himself).  And Dumbledore said that those who can love cannot be truely corrupted. I think that if the Death Eaters hadn't intervened, Malfoy would have joined Dumbledore.</blockquote>