Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="kreynolds" data-source="post: 443780" data-attributes="member: 2829">Actually, I did read your posts, and I couldn't figure out two things.1) The contradiction in your statements.2) Why you're being so frickin' rude. Read on to see more of this unprovoked behavior.That's right, but you also infer that if the item you want doesn't already exist, then you can't make it.Yes, you made your stance clear. I'm not challenging what you said. I'm questioning your reasoning. Big difference.So, if the item hasn't already been made by WotC, then it's not an official item, but they're not saying that you can't make one. That's much better stated. Thank you for clearing that up.See, it's this kind of thing that destroyed any validity to your argument for me. You said if the item isn't listed, then you don't have permission to make it, which is evident by your first post, and wasn't cleared up by your second post either. Yet now, you're adding in a little caveat, which is &quot;If it falls within the rules of magic item creation, you can make it.&quot;What does this translate to? Very simple; &quot;If you have the Brew Potion feat, and the spell you have prepared targets a creature, you can brew the potion. You will probably need to seek DM approval before you make a potion that is not listed in the DMG.&quot;That's a far cry from &quot;They said no.&quot;I think we're clear now.No need. I'm not having any difficulty in reading your posts. I'm having difficulty making sense of your argument.I didn't miss anything. I just didn't think your argument was very valid and I found it contradictory.See previous answers, and please, calm down. I certainly don't deserve this kinda of crappy behavior from you. I'm being civil. I would hope it's not too much to ask for you to do the same.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="kreynolds, post: 443780, member: 2829"] Actually, I did read your posts, and I couldn't figure out two things. 1) The contradiction in your statements. 2) Why you're being so frickin' rude. Read on to see more of this unprovoked behavior. That's right, but you also infer that if the item you want doesn't already exist, then you can't make it. Yes, you made your stance clear. I'm not challenging what you said. I'm questioning your reasoning. Big difference. So, if the item hasn't already been made by WotC, then it's not an official item, but they're not saying that you can't make one. That's much better stated. Thank you for clearing that up. See, it's this kind of thing that destroyed any validity to your argument for me. You said if the item isn't listed, then you don't have permission to make it, which is evident by your first post, and wasn't cleared up by your second post either. Yet now, you're adding in a little caveat, which is "If it falls within the rules of magic item creation, you can make it." What does this translate to? Very simple; "If you have the Brew Potion feat, and the spell you have prepared targets a creature, you can brew the potion. You will probably need to seek DM approval before you make a potion that is not listed in the DMG." That's a far cry from "They said no." I think we're clear now. No need. I'm not having any difficulty in reading your posts. I'm having difficulty making sense of your argument. I didn't miss anything. I just didn't think your argument was very valid and I found it contradictory. See previous answers, and please, calm down. I certainly don't deserve this kinda of crappy behavior from you. I'm being civil. I would hope it's not too much to ask for you to do the same. [/QUOTE]

Verification