Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Ruin Explorer" data-source="post: 8891962" data-attributes="member: 18">This post makes literally no sense. I have to ask, with respect, are you using Google translate or something to translate from a non-English language?This bolded bit is absolutely nonsensical in English. It literally makes no sense. First off, it claims the DMG only &quot;shortly and vaguely&quot; talks about firearms (we shall ignore &quot;very openly&quot;, that's got to be a typo or artifact, doesn't make sense), which is patently false. Also it's quoting someone? Why?[URL unfurl=&quot;true&quot;]https://www.dndbeyond.com/sources/dmg/dungeon-masters-workshop#Firearms[/URL]The DMG has 10 firearms, and special rules for reloading, burst fire, and ammunition for firearms. That's neither &quot;short&quot; nor &quot;vague&quot;. That's quite detailed.Your next sentence then says &quot;These came no sooner than October 2017, and another portion in July 2020&quot;. What is &quot;these&quot; in this sentence? Logically, it appears to be referring to the DMG, but it's obviously not true. The DMG came out in 2014.Then we have some stuff about an Artificer UA - is that the firearms UA you're referring to?Further, AFAIK, there's literally ONE Feat that supports firearms, Gunner. You refer to Feats plural, what are the rest? What books are they in?I mean, it's looks like you're using some kind of translation software here, or quoting someone else. If either is true, that's causing a problem, to be clear.But let's try one more time:Where, exactly, are the D&amp;D rules that you're claiming are taken from the Gunslinger homebrew? And where can I find the Gunslinger homebrew they were taken from?EDIT: LOL are you going to say the Exandria book? Because I'm guessing that's it. That is Matt Mercer's work, just published by WotC...</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Ruin Explorer, post: 8891962, member: 18"] This post makes literally no sense. I have to ask, with respect, are you using Google translate or something to translate from a non-English language? This bolded bit is absolutely nonsensical in English. It literally makes no sense. First off, it claims the DMG only "shortly and vaguely" talks about firearms (we shall ignore "very openly", that's got to be a typo or artifact, doesn't make sense), which is patently false. Also it's quoting someone? Why? [URL unfurl="true"]https://www.dndbeyond.com/sources/dmg/dungeon-masters-workshop#Firearms[/URL] The DMG has 10 firearms, and special rules for reloading, burst fire, and ammunition for firearms. That's neither "short" nor "vague". That's quite detailed. Your next sentence then says "[B]These came no sooner than October 2017, and another portion in July 2020"[/B]. What is "these" in this sentence? Logically, it appears to be referring to the DMG, but it's obviously not true. The DMG came out in 2014. Then we have some stuff about an Artificer UA - is that the firearms UA you're referring to? Further, AFAIK, there's literally ONE Feat that supports firearms, Gunner. You refer to Feats plural, what are the rest? What books are they in? I mean, it's looks like you're using some kind of translation software here, or quoting someone else. If either is true, that's causing a problem, to be clear. But let's try one more time: Where, exactly, are the D&D rules that you're claiming are taken from the Gunslinger homebrew? And where can I find the Gunslinger homebrew they were taken from? EDIT: LOL are you going to say the Exandria book? Because I'm guessing that's it. That is Matt Mercer's work, just published by WotC... [/QUOTE]

Verification