Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Umbran" data-source="post: 438033" data-attributes="member: 177">What's in a name?  A skill by any other name still has the same DC...To my mind, the question is worrthy of thought, but not because there's a question of whether herbalism is making something, or providing a service.  The root question is - who is supposed to have access to the skill?If you make it a Craft, then everyone has access to it as a class skill.  That doesn't sound right.  If you make it a profession, the only core classes who don't have it as a class skill are Barbarians and Fighters.  That still seems like too many having easy access.  So, it seems that it really needs it's own skill, akin to Alchemy.</blockquote>