Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="fimp" data-source="post: 2012371" data-attributes="member: 4156">I think you break some of your own &quot;Review Rules&quot; with your review on this product.The moderators will delete any reviews that they feel do not constitute a true review. A review is an in-depth look at a specific product, with well-thought out comments and criticisms. A review which consists of &quot;This product is useless, do not buy it!&quot; is of no use to anybody and a waste of EN World's resources (each review effectively costs me money and I only wish to spend that money if it is of some use). Such reviews will be deleted without warning.In-depth? Where?Your review should be of a reasonable length. Although there is no set limit, some reviews are better described as &quot;comments&quot;. Those reviews will be deleted, or may be posted by the moderators as a comment rather than a review. Modertors may ask you, via a comment, to expand on your review before they delete it so as to give you a fair warning. I certainly wouldn't call this a &quot;long&quot; review!If you have a particular dislike for a particular product type, don't review it. If you hate character sheets and think they are useless, don't give a character sheet product a bad score. Some people like them, y'know! Instead, rate the product as a character sheet - if it's a good character sheet, give it a good review; if it's a bad character sheet, give it a bad review. Don't bother giving it a bad review because you hate character sheets - that helps nobody. It's like asking you to review knitting patterns and you just posting &quot;I hate knitting patterns&quot; in every review - it's no use to those people who are looking for knitting pattern reviews and who want to know which are the good knitting patterns and which are the bad ones.With &quot;If you have gamed for a while, you'll find it condescending as it tells you things you already know.&quot; i think you broke this one too.Not to say that this is such a bad review, but if other people should follow your rules, i think you should too.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="fimp, post: 2012371, member: 4156"] I think you break some of your own "Review Rules" with your review on this product. [i]The moderators will delete any reviews that they feel do not constitute a true review. A review is an in-depth look at a specific product, with well-thought out comments and criticisms. A review which consists of "This product is useless, do not buy it!" is of no use to anybody and a waste of EN World's resources (each review effectively costs me money and I only wish to spend that money if it is of some use). Such reviews will be deleted without warning.[/i] In-depth? Where? [i]Your review should be of a reasonable length. Although there is no set limit, some reviews are better described as "comments". Those reviews will be deleted, or may be posted by the moderators as a comment rather than a review. Modertors may ask you, via a comment, to expand on your review before they delete it so as to give you a fair warning. [/i] I certainly wouldn't call this a "long" review! [i]If you have a particular dislike for a particular product type, don't review it. If you hate character sheets and think they are useless, don't give a character sheet product a bad score. Some people like them, y'know! Instead, rate the product as a character sheet - if it's a good character sheet, give it a good review; if it's a bad character sheet, give it a bad review. Don't bother giving it a bad review because you hate character sheets - that helps nobody. It's like asking you to review knitting patterns and you just posting "I hate knitting patterns" in every review - it's no use to those people who are looking for knitting pattern reviews and who want to know which are the good knitting patterns and which are the bad ones.[/i] With "If you have gamed for a while, you'll find it condescending as it tells you things you already know." i think you broke this one too. Not to say that this is such a bad review, but if other people should follow your rules, i think you should too. [/QUOTE]

Verification