Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Mystic_23" data-source="post: 1043979" data-attributes="member: 11693">Wow.  I'm impressed.  Gregor quoted Henry's post BEFORE Henry even posted it.  He's some sort of ENWorld psychic.However, to keep this thread on topic, I agree with Henry.  If you're trying to go for a gritty game, I'd say go for it.  But I wouldn't want to play in a regular D&D game using that system.  My problem is rolling the stats in order and keeping them that way.  I don't really care to be pidgeonholed into playing one particular class by what stats I get.  "Gee...I can only play a fighter...again."Of course, I'm not trying to tell you how to play the game.  If everyone in the group enjoys playing that way, that's fine.  I've even played that way and had a good time.  I played a game like that where the best stat I had was a 12 dex.  I made  a rogue who wasn't exactly great at it.  I agree it helped to roleplay.  I played him as a down-on-his-luck commoner who turned to thievary because it was all he could do.  (This was 2nd ed, so don't read anything into "commoner".)I'd be interested in finding out how your CoC game goes. Have fun</blockquote>