Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Tovec" data-source="post: 5934829" data-attributes="member: 95493">I don't actually disagree with you on these points. I was just saying&nbsp; that I think magic refreshes on a night's sleep because HP does, not&nbsp; that HP does because that's when magic does.Sadly yes this is true. And I do happen to agree that HP doesn't represent any aspect of fighting very well. My point is solely that in terms of DnD, they aren't actually trying to draw blood so that may pertain more to why boxers regaining stamina in a fight more resembles 4e's healing surges (and healing) than the HS and healing resemble reality.The former being: That you should recover HP somewhere safe, etc?And the latter being: That you shouldn't willy nilly as long as you aren't getting attacked?I'm surprised you disagree at all with this last part. Are you saying that you agree that they should regain HP in safety, town, nice bed but disagree and say they should be able to recoup in the wilderness/dungeon too? I don't understand here.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Tovec, post: 5934829, member: 95493"] I don't actually disagree with you on these points. I was just saying that I think magic refreshes on a night's sleep because HP does, not that HP does because that's when magic does. Sadly yes this is true. And I do happen to agree that HP doesn't represent any aspect of fighting very well. My point is solely that in terms of DnD, they aren't actually trying to draw blood so that may pertain more to why boxers regaining stamina in a fight more resembles 4e's healing surges (and healing) than the HS and healing resemble reality. The former being: That you should recover HP somewhere safe, etc? And the latter being: That you shouldn't willy nilly as long as you aren't getting attacked? I'm surprised you disagree at all with this last part. Are you saying that you agree that they should regain HP in safety, town, nice bed but disagree and say they should be able to recoup in the wilderness/dungeon too? I don't understand here. [/QUOTE]

Verification