Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Herobizkit" data-source="post: 5262586" data-attributes="member: 36150">Based on the other two's interests, I may be out before I even get in.For me:3.5 is ok, Pathfinder is better (with 3.5 prestige classes, of course).&nbsp; 4e would be nice to get a first look at the rules in action from level 1, but seems too &quot;rulesy&quot; for PbP.2e is right out for me, and I know nothing about the Dragon Age rules/setting.d20 Modern/Past and even True20 would work well for a Semi-real game... but I was looking for something a touch more fantastic, believe it or not.&nbsp; Still, PotC/Indy-type game would be interesting.IMO, tactical game-play does not suit PbP well, and doesn't suit me at all.&nbsp; I feel that a narrative-driven game played out like an ep of Hercules/Xena to be ideal... ie the 'minions' are always 'minions' unless they're important.&nbsp; 4e 'got it right' in that regard, if you ask me.I have other PbP's with both of the above players, and I was hoping to play with a new bunch of people.&nbsp; We'll just wait and see on this one.&nbsp; I'm in, but I don't know for how long.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Herobizkit, post: 5262586, member: 36150"] Based on the other two's interests, I may be out before I even get in. For me: 3.5 is ok, Pathfinder is better (with 3.5 prestige classes, of course). 4e would be nice to get a first look at the rules in action from level 1, but seems too "rulesy" for PbP. 2e is right out for me, and I know nothing about the Dragon Age rules/setting. d20 Modern/Past and even True20 would work well for a Semi-real game... but I was looking for something a touch more fantastic, believe it or not. Still, PotC/Indy-type game would be interesting. IMO, tactical game-play does not suit PbP well, and doesn't suit me at all. I feel that a narrative-driven game played out like an ep of Hercules/Xena to be ideal... ie the 'minions' are always 'minions' unless they're important. 4e 'got it right' in that regard, if you ask me. I have other PbP's with both of the above players, and I was hoping to play with a new bunch of people. We'll just wait and see on this one. I'm in, but I don't know for how long. [/QUOTE]

Verification