Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Particle_Man" data-source="post: 5722554" data-attributes="member: 892">So your solution is to make the illusionist do a heck of a lot of advance prep (which often only works for NPC stationary illusionists, rather than PC mobile illusionists).&nbsp; My solution is to have DM fail to detect illusions, period.I have yet to hear anyone say that my house rule would be a disaster for the game, or even in any way a bad thing (although I have seen one person come up with a more complicated alternative that they like, but which I see as roughly a mirror image of &quot;DM doesn't work on illusions unless you make a DC will save vs. the spell).&nbsp; I have heard people say it is a good thing.So I think, if my house rule is seen by some as a good thing, and others as a neutral thing, and by no one as a bad thing, that this would solve the problem for those that see it as a problem.&nbsp; Like, if some d20 game game out with my house rule, would people complain about the now-godlike power of illusionists?&nbsp; So far, I haven't heard this.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Particle_Man, post: 5722554, member: 892"] So your solution is to make the illusionist do a heck of a lot of advance prep (which often only works for NPC stationary illusionists, rather than PC mobile illusionists). My solution is to have DM fail to detect illusions, period. I have yet to hear anyone say that my house rule would be a disaster for the game, or even in any way a bad thing (although I have seen one person come up with a more complicated alternative that they like, but which I see as roughly a mirror image of "DM doesn't work on illusions unless you make a DC will save vs. the spell). I have heard people say it is a good thing. So I think, if my house rule is seen by some as a good thing, and others as a neutral thing, and by no one as a bad thing, that this would solve the problem for those that see it as a problem. Like, if some d20 game game out with my house rule, would people complain about the now-godlike power of illusionists? So far, I haven't heard this. [/QUOTE]

Verification