Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="catsclaw227" data-source="post: 4569366" data-attributes="member: 14197">I thought the adventure was just OK.&nbsp;I agree, path or not, that's irrelevant.&nbsp; I was very impressed with the materials, the maps, the way the adventure was designed physically.&nbsp; The adventure was very basic, very geared towards beginners.&nbsp; I ran it with some newbies, and they had a great time. RHoD, that would have much more difficult and would NOT have had the &quot;fun&quot; effect I was looking for for new players.&nbsp; For that purpose (and, quite frankly, the one that was intended), it was better than RHoD, which was an awesome adventure.... for experienced players and DMs. &nbsp;Of course, this goes without saying that this is only your opinion, and not stated fact.&nbsp; My opinion differs.I love Necro products, I own almost all.&nbsp; I own the first 2 Paizo APs fully, and MANY of their products. The physical quality of H1 was superior than any Necro adventure, and better than the first RotR adventure, again, in my opinion.&nbsp; As for the gaming quality, I already stated that it was full of win for the new people I gamed with.&nbsp;&nbsp;I am not going to dig around for the threads where Clark and many others have stated that the people at WoTC care about the 3PP.&nbsp; Just ask the publishers themselves.&nbsp;Again, this is an over-simplistic view of things.&nbsp; Running a business for the past 15 years has proven this to me.&nbsp;Well, for what it's worth, I disagree.&nbsp; Scott represents WOTC, he speaks for them.&nbsp; So when he says that they care about the 3PP, then it is WOTC saying it.&nbsp; Let's not dance around semantics.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="catsclaw227, post: 4569366, member: 14197"] I thought the adventure was just OK. I agree, path or not, that's irrelevant. I was very impressed with the materials, the maps, the way the adventure was designed physically. The adventure was very basic, very geared towards beginners. I ran it with some newbies, and they had a great time. RHoD, that would have much more difficult and would NOT have had the "fun" effect I was looking for for new players. For that purpose (and, quite frankly, the one that was intended), it was better than RHoD, which was an awesome adventure.... for experienced players and DMs. Of course, this goes without saying that this is only your opinion, and not stated fact. My opinion differs. I love Necro products, I own almost all. I own the first 2 Paizo APs fully, and MANY of their products. The physical quality of H1 was superior than any Necro adventure, and better than the first RotR adventure, again, in my opinion. As for the gaming quality, I already stated that it was full of win for the new people I gamed with. I am not going to dig around for the threads where Clark and many others have stated that the people at WoTC care about the 3PP. Just ask the publishers themselves. Again, this is an over-simplistic view of things. Running a business for the past 15 years has proven this to me. Well, for what it's worth, I disagree. Scott represents WOTC, he speaks for them. So when he says that they care about the 3PP, then it is WOTC saying it. Let's not dance around semantics. [/QUOTE]

Verification