Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="werecorpse" data-source="post: 6771527" data-attributes="member: 55491">Many pcs in the games I play track who is the best at killing bad guys a la Legolas &amp; Gimli. And I wasn't saying average kills I was saying given the average of dice one may notice over time that a longsword packs more punch.I don't agree with Saelorn's position, partly because of the absolutism that it is clear to all what weapon is better. Neither do I accept the absolutism that it is &quot;just not noticeable&quot;. My position is a character may react to the evidence before it. If it shows maces as being utterly rubbishy compared to war hammers (and it might) then go for it.The gaming world is variable.I haven't answered the quiz yet but my answer is that my pcs are somewhat cognisant of the rules but not to the level of Saelorn. They act according to their own experience and tales of those they trust, not the accumulated wisdom of someone who &quot;knows the rules&quot;</blockquote>

[QUOTE="werecorpse, post: 6771527, member: 55491"] Many pcs in the games I play track who is the best at killing bad guys a la Legolas & Gimli. And I wasn't saying average kills I was saying given the average of dice one may notice over time that a longsword packs more punch. I don't agree with Saelorn's position, partly because of the absolutism that it is clear to all what weapon is better. Neither do I accept the absolutism that it is "just not noticeable". My position is a character may react to the evidence before it. If it shows maces as being utterly rubbishy compared to war hammers (and it might) then go for it. The gaming world is variable. I haven't answered the quiz yet but my answer is that my pcs are somewhat cognisant of the rules but not to the level of Saelorn. They act according to their own experience and tales of those they trust, not the accumulated wisdom of someone who "knows the rules" [/QUOTE]

Verification