Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="muppetmuppet" data-source="post: 7614496" data-attributes="member: 6800767">SPOILERS FOR LFR ASSAULT ON MYTH NANTAR.I had some player on player dice rolling in the last session which is very unusual for my games.&nbsp; One player had got into his hand a glowing green thing of very dubious nature which the party believed may have been animating an undead.So one other player asked him to put it down on the ground until they decided what to do with it just in case it was dangerous.&nbsp; I had passed a note to the player saying he wouldn't do this expecting the party to ask this, it is pretty much their go to move in this kind of situation. Next one player made a quick grab for the item which the first player was holding in one hand reasonably openly in front of them looking into it.&nbsp; This needed a player vs player roll.&nbsp; The second player succeeded and now had the item.&nbsp; Aha would you like to place that on the ground say the rest.&nbsp; &quot;No&quot; says player 2.&nbsp; Player 2 holds the item carefully and tightly.&nbsp; A couple of strong characters now grapple player 2's PC.&nbsp; The item is carefully prised from her grip and player 3 is now asked to put the item down.&nbsp; Predictably he refuses.&nbsp; The half orc tries to intimidate player 3 by saying put down the item or I will chop off your arm.&nbsp; This was a social skill which I rule cannot be decided by dice between pc's so player 3 merely has to answer or do whatever he thinks is sensible.&nbsp; In fact in this case it would not have mattered because player 3 wasn't going to put the item down even if the intimidate is successful.&nbsp; The grapple plan began again but player 3 teleported away.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="muppetmuppet, post: 7614496, member: 6800767"] SPOILERS FOR LFR ASSAULT ON MYTH NANTAR. I had some player on player dice rolling in the last session which is very unusual for my games. One player had got into his hand a glowing green thing of very dubious nature which the party believed may have been animating an undead. So one other player asked him to put it down on the ground until they decided what to do with it just in case it was dangerous. I had passed a note to the player saying he wouldn't do this expecting the party to ask this, it is pretty much their go to move in this kind of situation. Next one player made a quick grab for the item which the first player was holding in one hand reasonably openly in front of them looking into it. This needed a player vs player roll. The second player succeeded and now had the item. Aha would you like to place that on the ground say the rest. "No" says player 2. Player 2 holds the item carefully and tightly. A couple of strong characters now grapple player 2's PC. The item is carefully prised from her grip and player 3 is now asked to put the item down. Predictably he refuses. The half orc tries to intimidate player 3 by saying put down the item or I will chop off your arm. This was a social skill which I rule cannot be decided by dice between pc's so player 3 merely has to answer or do whatever he thinks is sensible. In fact in this case it would not have mattered because player 3 wasn't going to put the item down even if the intimidate is successful. The grapple plan began again but player 3 teleported away. [/QUOTE]

Verification